How we score
Each provider is scored on business activity, working contact details, replies, and reported work. Each score shows the evidence behind it and when it was recorded.
Scores change as evidence gets older. The rules below explain how recent the evidence needs to be and how reports affect each score.
1 · Open
Still in business?
Recent posts, reviews, website updates, and replies help confirm that they’re still operating.
- Open
- Business activity dated within the last 12 months
- Probably open
- The latest business activity is more than 12 and no more than 24 months old
- Gone quiet
- The latest business activity is more than 24 months old
- Closed
- A source says they've closed or retired
- Not confirmed yet
- We haven't found dated business activity
2 · Reachable
Can you reach them?
We check that websites load and that email domains are set up and still registered. People who’ve reached them confirm which contact details work.
- Reachable
- Someone reached them using the listed contact details in the last 12 months
- Probably reachable
- In the last 90 days, the website loaded or the email address’s domain was set up for mail (a Gmail or similar address counts), or a phone number check is less than a year old
- Listed, not confirmed
- Contact details are published but haven't been confirmed
- Some / all contact info doesn't work
- Checks or contact reports found a disconnected number, bounced email, or unavailable website. A newer result takes precedence.
- No contact info
- No phone number, email address, website, or Facebook page is listed
3 · Responds
Do they get back to you?
People record whether they heard back and how long it took. A recent Facebook reply badge can also count.
- Gets back to people
- They replied to at least 75% of reported contact attempts
- Hit or miss
- They replied to at least 40% but fewer than 75% of reported contact attempts
- Hard to reach
- They replied to fewer than 40% of reported contact attempts
- Probably responds
- Too few reports, but Facebook’s fast-reply badge was recorded in the last 12 months
- No reports yet / Too few reports
- Fewer than 2 contact reports from the last 24 months, with no recent Facebook reply badge
4 · Does the work
Do they show up and do the work?
People report whether a provider showed up and whether they’d hire them again.
- Shows up, does the work
- Showed up for at least 80% of reported jobs, and at least as many people would hire them again as wouldn't
- Mixed results
- Showed up for at least 50% of reported jobs, but fewer than 80% or more people wouldn't hire them again
- Often doesn't show
- Showed up for fewer than 50% of reported jobs
- No reports yet / Too few reports
- Fewer than 2 attendance reports and fewer than 2 hire-again answers
Where the evidence comes from
- The public web. Business pages, Facebook, Instagram, maps, reviews, and town and chamber directories, checked on a rolling schedule. Facts from the web are marked with and link to where we found them. Public star ratings and general community mentions are shown for context but never change a score.
- Automated checks. Scripts test whether websites load and email domains are set up for mail, look up when a business’s own domain was registered and whether it has lapsed, look for dated posts on business websites, and read public Facebook pages and Google Maps listings for the newest post, review, and owner reply. A Google listing counts only if the business links to it or it shows the same phone number. A domain set up for mail doesn’t confirm that an individual email address works. A domain registered again after we first saw the business’s site may belong to someone else now, so it’s reviewed before the listing changes. An address counts as confirmed when their own website, Facebook Page or Google listing shows the same street address; addresses don’t change a score. Automatically updated sitemap dates do not establish that a business is still operating, and no script marks a business closed.
- Service areas. We keep a business’s base separate from the places it says it serves, with sources and dates. A vague region or travel radius is not expanded into towns. Service-specific restrictions and travel conditions appear on the provider’s page.
- Contact and job reports. After contacting a provider, you can record whether they replied, could take the job, showed up, and whether you’d hire them again. Reports saved from projects count the same way. Only reports from the last 24 months count.
For the work score, we need at least 2 attendance reports or 2 hire-again answers. If there are no attendance reports, the score uses the hire-again answers alone. An unanswered hire-again question doesn’t count as a negative answer.
How the list is sorted
“Highest score” adds the four scores together, with Responds weighted one and a half times as much as each of the others. An unknown result counts the same as a mixed result and more than a negative result. Closed providers appear last.
When you pick where the job is, distance counts too: every 10 miles between a provider’s base town and yours takes off one point (the gap between Open and Probably open), and anyone who lists your town as a service area counts as local. Nobody is hidden for coverage we don’t know: a provider whose base we don’t know counts as 20 miles away, and one who says they don’t serve your town is listed last.
Report review and privacy
We need at least 2 contact reports to score replies, unless a recent Facebook badge supports “Probably responds.” Reports that appear to come from the business itself, a competitor, or repeated submissions from the same person may count for less.
Your projects, notes, and contact history aren’t shown publicly. Public listings show combined report totals.
To report a missing provider or incorrect details, use “Suggest a provider.”